Are fixed rates the borrower’s best bet, or could you end up paying over the odds? Christina Jordan of Your Mortgage magazine looks at locking into a rate
Sometimes you might feel like taking a gamble, doing something a little bit risky or completely losing control. That’s fair enough and even the most sensible of us appreciate the need for a thrill once in a while. But if you’re feeling the need to spice up your life, don’t go too far. By all means put an extra pound on the lottery or drink that extra pint, but if you are going to take a gamble don’t risk the roof over your head. Choose your mortgage carefully.
Fix it?
One of the most important decisions to make when taking out a mortgage is how you want the interest to be charged, as this can affect the level of your monthly payments. You can either go for a variable rate (which often comes with a discount) where the rate goes up and down in line with the Bank of England base rate, or you can go for a fixed rate where the rate is set for an agreed term.
Fixed rates are extremely popular with borrowers, accounting for just over 50 per cent of all mortgage lending in May this year according to the Council of Mortgage Lenders (CML). This figure has risen steeply from just 27 per cent in May 2002, so what is it about the current market that is prompting borrowers to fix their interest rate?
The Bank of England base rate can shoulder some of the responsibility as, at 3.5 per cent, it’s at its lowest level for 50 years. And the base rate influences mortgage rates so many lenders have reduced their rates to historically low levels, making servicing a mortgage debt more affordable than ever. The average fixed rate in May was 4.21 per cent according to the CML. On a £100,000 25-year repayment mortgage this would equate to monthly repayments of just £539.50. It’s understandable that many borrowers want to fix while rates are this low to protect themselves from future interest rate rises, despite the fact that some industry experts believe they could fall even further.
Colin Dale, head of lending at Skipton Building Society, agrees that borrowers are very keen to fix in the current environment. ‘Over the last couple of months people have been locking themselves into rates. We don’t expect mortgage rates to come down that much more regardless of what happens to the base rate. There has to be a floor.
‘Consumers are also worried that rates could start to rise, and there is also the possibility that the housing market could be on the turn. So those who have stretched their finances to buy are more comfortable with a fixed rate, giving them certainty with their payments.’
Pros and cons
The benefits of taking out a fixed rate mortgage are pretty clear. First and foremost they offer security. And when you have the initial costs of a house purchase plus bills to consider, payment stability can be extremely important. As Sarah King, spokesperson for Nationwide, reiterates: ‘With a fixed rate mortgage your interest rate will be frozen for a number of years – ideal if you want the reassurance of knowing exactly what your mortgage payments will be each month. It also protects you from rising interest rates.’
So if the base rate were to rise your payments would be unaffected, as your lender cannot change your rate until the agreed period is over and you revert to the standard variable rate. However, if interest rates were to fall you could find yourself paying over the odds. This is the main drawback of a fixed rate – you cannot benefit from a drop in rates.
Many fixed rate deals come with redemption penalties so that if rates do drop and you want to move to another deal, you may find you are locked into your mortgage and the only way you can move is to pay a fee. In addition, because the lender is offering you security with a fixed rate, they are usually priced slightly higher than discounted variable rate products. While they remain very competitive, fixed rates are unlikely to be the cheapest products on the market.
Take the risk
Whether you go for a discounted variable or a fixed rate there is always some sort of risk attached and you are the only person who can decide what is most appropriate for you. A discounted rate will probably offer the cheapest initial deal, but if the base rate rises it is likely your mortgage rate will too. And there is no guarantee that rates will not rise significantly so your monthly payments could, in theory, double. The risk with a fixed rate it is that variable rates could drop significantly and the rate you have fixed at could be a lot higher than the average mortgage rate. But at least you will be able to budget precisely and afford your own repayments.
The long game
In his budget speech in April Chancellor Gordon Brown announced that he has commissioned academic Professor David Miles to look into why long-term fixed rates are not a bigger part of the UK mortgage market. In Europe and the US, long-term fixed rates (e.g. over 15 years) are much more prevalent than here. But in fact there is a handful of long-term fixed rates on the market which cater for those borrowers who want long-term security. However, British borrowers traditionally prefer a shorter fixed rate, typically between two and five years, so that they can re-evaluate the market at the end of this period.
According to Nationwide, its two- and five-year fixed rate mortgages are currently the most popular products in its mortgage range.